CAARS 2 Manual Appendix B: Omitted Items |
The Conners ADHD Rating Scale 2nd Edition (CAARS™ 2) results may be less accurate if responses are missing. If the
allowable number of omitted responses has been exceeded for a given scale (see Table B.1),
the scale cannot be
scored and is displayed as “?” in the reports. This question mark indicates that the scale cannot be scored due to
too many omitted responses. Some scales can be prorated if the maximum number of allowable omissions has not been
exceeded, including the following scales: Content Scales, DSM Symptom Scales (T-scores only), and the CAARS™
2–ADHD
Index. Raw scores for these scales are prorated with the following formula:
For example, a rater obtained a raw score of 10, but answered only 5 out of 6 items on a particular scale. The score
may be prorated by multiplying the obtained raw score of 10 by the number of items (6) on the full scale (10 × 6 =
60). The obtained result is then divided by the number of completed items on the scale (5) to get the prorated raw
score of 12 (60 ÷ 5). The prorated raw score accounts for the missing items and adjusts the total raw score based on
how the rater answered the other items on the scale. Prorating is automatically implemented where applicable.
Table B.1. Maximum Number of Allowable Item Omissions for CAARS 2 Scales
Scale
|
CAARS 2
|
CAARS 2–Short
|
Self-Report
|
Observer
|
Self-Report
|
Observer
|
Content Scales
|
Inattention/Executive Dysfunction
|
2
|
2
|
1
|
1
|
Hyperactivity
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Impulsivity
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Emotional Dysregulation
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Negative Self-Concept
|
1
|
1
|
-
|
-
|
DSM Symptom Scales
|
ADHD Inattentive Symptoms
|
1*
|
1*
|
-
|
-
|
ADHD Hyperactive/Impulsive Symptoms
|
1*
|
1*
|
-
|
-
|
Total ADHD Symptoms
|
2*
|
2*
|
-
|
-
|
Index
|
CAARS 2-ADHD Index
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Note.
*The maximum number of allowable item omissions are for the DSM Symptom Scale T-scores and do not apply to Symptom
Counts.
Omissions are handled differently for the Negative Impression Index, the Inconsistency Index, and the DSM Symptom
Counts. These will be discussed in detail in subsequent sections.
Omitted Items for the Negative Impression Index
The Negative Impression Index cannot be prorated. When Negative Impression Index item responses are missing, the
following rules are applied in order:
-
If the raw score (based on the items that were rated) is equal to, or higher than, the cut-off (for values,
see Table 4.1
in chapter 4,
Interpretation), then the status of “Warrants
follow up” is provided,
regardless of
how many items have been omitted (see Example 1 in Table B.2).
-
If the raw score (based on the items that were rated) plus the number of missing items multiplied by three is
lower than the minimum cut-off, then the status of “Within the expected range” is provided (see Example 2
in
Table B.2).
-
If neither of the above two conditions is met, then the status of the Negative Impression Index is “Could not
be scored due to omitted item(s)” (see Example 3 in Table B.2).
Table B.2. Samples of Negative Impression Index Interpreted with Omitted Items: CAARS 2 Self-Report
Example
|
Raw Score
|
Number of Omitted Items
|
Cut-Off
|
Guideline
|
Explanation
|
1
|
7
|
1
|
≥ 6
|
Warrants follow-up
|
The cut-off (6) has been exceeded by the Raw Score (7), regardless of
the omitted items. This score may be an underestimate.
|
2
|
0
|
1
|
≥ 6
|
Within the expected range
|
The cut-off (6) cannot be met or exceeded.
|
3
|
3
|
1
|
≥ 6
|
Could not be scored due to omitted item(s)
|
Depending on the value for the omitted item, the cut-off could either be
met (e.g., if the omitted item score = 3, the Raw Score = 3 + 3 = 6) or
not met (e.g., if the omitted item score = 2, the Raw Score = 3 + 2 =
5). Because of this ambiguity, the score cannot be interpreted.
|
Note.
The Raw Score is based on the items that were rated.
Omitted Items for the Inconsistency Index
When Inconsistency Index item responses are missing, the following rules are applied, in order:
-
If the raw score (based on the item pairs that were rated) is equal to, or higher than, the cut-off (for
values, see Table
4.2
in chapter 4,
Interpretation), then the status of “Warrants follow-up” is provided,
regardless of how many item pairs have been omitted (see Example 1 in Table B.3).
-
If the raw score (based on the item pairs that were rated) plus the number of missing items multiplied by
three is lower than the minimum cut-off, then the status of “Within the expected range” is provided (see
Example
2 in Table B.3).
-
If neither of the above two conditions is met, then the status of the Inconsistency Index is “Could not be
scored due to omitted item(s)” (see Example 3 in Table B.3).
Table B.3. Samples of Inconsistency Index Interpreted with Omitted Items: CAARS 2 Self-Report
Example
|
Raw Score
|
Number of Omitted Item Pairs
|
Cut-Off
|
Guideline
|
Explanation
|
1
|
5
|
1
|
≥ 4
|
Warrants follow-up
|
The cut-off (4) has been exceeded by the Raw Score (5), regardless of
the omitted items. This score may be an underestimate.
|
2
|
0
|
1
|
≥ 4
|
Within the expected range
|
The cut-off (4) cannot be met or exceeded. That is, even if the
difference between items in the omitted pair was 3, the score would be
below the cut-off.
|
3
|
1
|
1
|
≥ 4
|
Could not be scored due to omitted item(s)
|
Depending on the value for the omitted item pair difference, the cut-off
could either be met (e.g., if the omitted pair difference score = 3, the
Raw Score = 1 + 3 = 4) or not met (e.g., if the omitted pair difference
score = 0, the Raw Score = 1 + 0 = 1). Because of this ambiguity, the
score cannot be interpreted.
|
Note.
The Raw Score is based on the items that were rated.
Omitted Items for the DSM Symptom Counts
The DSM Symptom Counts cannot be prorated in the same manner as raw scores. When item responses are omitted, one
needs to determine if the symptom criteria outlined by the DSM are affected. In other words, if a single CAARS 2
item represents a DSM symptom, then the omission of the item means the symptom cannot be scored. Likewise, if a pair
of CAARS 2 items are both required to be present to assess a possible DSM symptom (i.e., “AND” criterion), then the
omission of either item means the symptom cannot be scored. In contrast, when either of two CAARS 2 items can be
used to represent a DSM symptom (i.e., “OR” criterion), then the omission of either item would permit partial
consideration of the symptom. (See appendix G for details about
how CAARS 2 items map onto DSM
symptom criteria).
The following rules are applied when Symptom Count items are missing:
-
If the omitted item(s) impacts one of the DSM symptoms, the Symptom Count will be provided, with a
note that
the Symptom Count may be an underestimation because the rater did not respond to all of the symptom criteria
(see Example 1 in Table B.4).
-
If the omitted items impact more than one of the DSM symptoms, there are two possible scenarios:
-
If the Symptom Count is below the DSM symptom count requirement, then the Symptom Count cannot be
provided for the scale, and instead, it is marked as “?” on digital reports to indicate that it cannot
be scored due to too many omitted responses (see Example 2 in Table B.4).
-
If the Symptom Count is at or above the DSM symptom count requirement, then the Symptom Count will
be provided; however, a note will indicate that the obtained Symptom Count may be an underestimation of
the actual Symptom Count because the rater did not respond to all the symptom criteria (see Example 3 in
Table B.4).
Table B.4. Samples of DSM ADHD Inattentive Symptoms Scale Symptom Count Interpreted with Omitted Items
Example
|
Partial Symptom Count
|
Number of Missing Symptoms
|
Symptom Count Reported
|
Explanation
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
1*/9
|
Symptom Count(s) may be underestimated due to omitted item(s).
|
2
|
1
|
2
|
?
|
Could not be scored due to omitted item(s).
|
3
|
8
|
2
|
8*/9
|
Symptom Count(s) may be underestimated due to omitted item(s).
|
Note.
The DSM-5-TR requires at least 5/9 symptoms for individuals ≥ 17 years of age.